Comment:
The MI (Manga Inc, formally AC or Anime Cartoon) version of Gundam X went on sale on ebay and other HK DVD selling sites last week. I thought it would be beneficial to write a review about the quality of the set, so that those interested in getting the series will know which set to get, and which set not to get.
The Basics:
5 DVD?s
Disk 1 = Episodes 1-9
Disk 2 = Episodes 10-18
Disk 3 = Episodes 19-27
Disk 4 = Episodes 28-36
Disk 5 = Episodes 37-39
I would have thought that an 8,8,8,8,7 arrangement would have made more sense. I also thought that adding extras on the 5th disk with all of the space available would have been a good idea with the arrangement used, we didn?t get either but it?s no big deal.
The main menu on every disk was the same, with the image of the first disk in the background. The three options you get on the main menu are the obvious ones; play, subtitles, and chapter select. When you select play, the little logo spins, that?s all the animation you get on that menu. The chapter select menu has running video in each episode box, which is great for a HK set.
One of the major improvements over the AS and AV sets is that the opening and ending sequences are included with every episode. Missing the opening sequence was terrible with the AS and AV versions, because you lost a minute or two of the show from every episode.
The opening and ending songs don?t have English subtitles. In the part of episode nine before the opening song, English subtitles for the opening song ran instead of the character text, which made for a rather humerus moment where it looked like the characters were singing the song and not saying their proper lines. Text about MI/AC is added to the opening song in every episode. It stays on the screen for around ten seconds and then disappears. Also, in every episode, the green M logo for MI appears in the top corner at the beginning of the first half of the episode for about ten seconds and then disappears. The same thing happens in the beginning of the second half as well.
Audio/Video:
Both audio and video were great for this set, very high quality in both aspects. There was one very minor problem. On the first three disks, everything froze for a second or two about halfway through, and then continued without skipping anything. This was probably due to the disk changing layers. If it happened on the fourth disk it must have been on a black screen because I didn?t notice it. That?s about it, I?m not like those pros that bitch about the slightest error in the audio and video. It looked good to me, and it sounded good to me, case closed!
Subtitles:
The other major problem with the AS and AV sets was that the subtitles were horrible on those sets. That?s not the case with this set, these subs are fansub quality. In some cases, the subs were better than those on my fansubs, since another (and better) fansub source was used. The text is also in a nice bold white color, so it?s easy to read. My fansubs had a habit of having different colors for the text as they went along.
There were a couple minor problems with the way the subtitles were presented however. First of all, on some parts of the set, some lines of text would have a question mark at the end of it whether it belonged there or not. This mainly happened on disks one and three, but it was easy to ignore, and it didn?t go on for long. Another problem was that the text would go off the screen at times. This happened every now and then until about halfway through disk three, where the problem almost disappeared. The text was never off the screen for disk four, and was rarely off the screen for disk five. The main problem was the timing problem. Most of the time the text ran perfectly, but at times it would be behind or ahead of the current text. At other times, they would have text for two different people on the same screen. It wasn?t that confusing to me since I?ve seen the series at least six times all the way through, but it may confuse someone new to the series a little.
Even with these minor problems, this is still the best HK set that I have ever seen subtitle wise. The grammar was great, and the spelling was great, NO ENGRISH! The only errors came when the first letter of a word would be missing, and this almost never happened.
Conclusion:
First of all, I?m glad that I got this set from florachanxxx. I won the auction last Monday night, and the set got to me (from HK) on that Friday afternoon. Thanks Flora! This is one of the best HK DVD sets on the market, and it is the best version of Gundam X that you?re going to get until the Bandai R1 releases a few years from now. There might be some minor errors and no extras, but if you?re a fan of Gundam X, then this is the set to get. When searching for the set, beware, do not buy the AS or AV versions of the set, you?ll be in a world of hurt if you do. Look for the green M logo on the box, and you?ll be in good shape. I hope that this review helped everyone, thank you for taking the time to read it.
Level: 3
Reviews: 2
Experience: 12,484
100%
(2) found this review useful