Video:
This is what got to my notice immidiately. The video on this part is noticably worse than on the first set. While the first set was a near-perfect rip with only minor pixelation, this one is a step backwards. First I must say I only completely watched the first episode, and spot-checked all the disc, through a lot of episodes.
First of all the pixelation is much worse on this set. On the first disc this might be logical, since it has 10 episodes on it. The 2nd disc has 9 episodes, and the last one only 7. But the last disc also has about 13 music video's, which take up about 50 minutes of time (!) in total.
In the first set there was only minor pixelation, that didn't bother me at all (a lot of people probably won't even notice it), but in this set it's definately worse. People who were bitching about the old Bebop set by FX, will most definately hate how this was ripped. Especially in the action scenes and the opening sequence there's pretty bad pixelation. While it's definately a bummer, I can live with it... looking at the price you pay for it. Still could've been a lot better though.
Overall the video looked a tad darker then the first set too, but this might have been like that in the R1 DVDs too. It also looked like there was a TINY ammount of ghosting in the darker scenes, but that could just as much have been my imagination.
UPDATE:
Now I've watched the complete set, and I must say things are looking better after the first 5 or so episodes. It seems to me the original R1 DVDs of the first 5 episodes were pretty dark too. The pixelation on the first DVD of this set is also worse then on the other 2 (since it has 10 episodes to it). There still is pixelation on the last 2 DVDs, still worse then Part 1 of this series, but not as bad as the first disc on this set.
Audio:
While it sounded a bit softer then the first set, it was still perfectly fine.
Since I didn't watch all episodes yet, I didn't find a sync problem. I'll edit this review if I find one.
UPDATE:
I found 2 episodes with VERY MINOR audio sync problems. I believe it were 43 and 45 or something like that. It was VERY minor, at first I didn't even notice it (since there weren't any major sound effects). I don't think this small a sync will bother people too much. Since the subtitles are still in perfect sync with the audio, I believe it's acutally the video that has the sync problem (lagging).
Don't let this drive you away from the set though, it's barely noticable.
Subtitle:
While it sounded a bit softer then the first set, it was still perfectly fine.
Since I didn't watch all episodes yet, I didn't find a sync problem. I'll edit this review if I find one.
UPDATE:
I found 2 episodes with VERY MINOR audio sync problems. I believe it were 43 and 45 or something like that. It was VERY minor, at first I didn't even notice it (since there weren't any major sound effects). I don't think this small a sync will bother people too much. Since the subtitles are still in perfect sync with the audio, I believe it's acutally the video that has the sync problem (lagging).
Don't let this drive you away from the set though, it's barely noticable.
Comment:
Overall it's a very good set, it's just the video that takes a step backwards from the first set. This is probably because they used quite a bit of space for the Music Video's. So it's just what you like... they could've lost the extra's for better video quality, oh well...
Now, if you think this set looks horrible, don't. It's still a DVD rip, just not a perfect one. If you're really bitchy about video quality, then you should just leave this set. Otherwise it's pretty much perfect.
Level: 8
Reviews: 51
Experience: 109,542
100%
(1) found this review useful