Comment:
The reviews of this two-part OAV have been mixed in terms of the quality of the anime....I'm on the "this is garbage" side of the mix. My breakdown:
Video (4.5/5): The video on this release is anamorphic widescreen and it is great. There are some slightly talked about green lines in some of the darker sequences but nothing particularly noticeable in my opinion. This anime in particular needs a good rip and it got it.
Audio (4.5/5.0): Again, DVD quality audio at its best in this case....maybe a little too loud but it's just a nitpick and might be more setup dependant. Great.
Subtitles (3.5/5.0): Pretty good overall, though there are a few typoes/misspellings and the translation is lacking slightly at points. Character names are correct and decent overall though.
Extras (3/5): Interviews with cast and crew.......unsubbed. Most HK DVD don't have interviews period though so I'll be generous.
Quality of Anime (1/5): Having seen the entire TV series, read all the manga, and having seen the prequel OVAs I was expecting a lot from this anime. Ideally I would have liked for them to make this a proper translation of the Jinchuu arc of the manga by going with a 4 or 5 part OVA. But instead they opted for something different, a jumbled/confused/confusing retelling of the entire series in 30 minutes in the first OVA and a 5 minute butchering of the Jinchuu arc in the second OVA following up with a lame story about Kenshin's son, Kenji, and his fight with Yahiko, and finally, the very weak tragic/happy ending. I tried to think of this from the perspective of standing alone from the TV series and the Manga, and if I judge it like that, the OVA makes no sense without a background in the series or manga and is garbage. And if I judge it from a standpoint of the experienced Kenshin viewer, I can't see how it can be anything else but a garbaged rehash of the series in the first OVA, and an equally mangled Jinchuu arc/Kenji and Yahiko storyline in the second. The only reason this anime even merits a star from me is because the soundtrack is great, the art is great, and when they animate the fight sequences between Kenshin and Jin-e, Kenshin and Enishi, and lastly, Kenji and Yahiko the animation is superb for the 2 minutes worth of fighting for these three "epic fights" combined. The tragic ending offends me so much as to compare it to a bad soap opera, something I never imagined I'd say with Kenshin. So finally, nothing wrong with video, audio, etc, if only the OVAs weren't utterly pathetic this would be a good release.
Level: 2
Reviews: 6
Experience: 7,836
100%
(1) found this review useful