Posts: 12
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2003
I have recently began to watch Lupin III on CN, and found it to be quite a good anime. Upon sharing this observation with a certain poster here, I was informed that it was horribly edited. So today I went to my local anime store, and I picked up a copy of the first dvd released by Pioneer, with 6 episodes on it. It was labeled 13+, and didn't say if it was edited or not. After watching it subbed with japanese text, it seems to be similar if not identical contentwise to the episodes I saw on CN. I am just wondering if the show and the dvds are really that horribly edited, or if I was given false information. Either way I am planning on ordering the HK boxset of the first season but would just like to know how badly the show has been butchered on it's US release.
Posts: 2,721
Threads: 100
Joined: Sep 2002
I am almost 100% sure it's highly edited. The show on CN is series 2 as I think you already know. The reason behind that is because season 1 was so full of naughtiness and other explicities. You are making a wise decision buying the HK of it all. Season 1 which is what you said you're getting is subbed quite perfectly. GOOD CHOICE MY FRIEND!!!
- The Original Lord Of Darkness -
"Ahh The Murthless Laugh of the Damned"
Posts: 12
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2003
That does explain why I had no clue what was going on even though I had supposedly seen the "first episode".
Posts: 1,549
Threads: 30
Joined: Sep 2002
Man, I gotta get the 1st series ASAP.
Heres something I learned from a FLCL episode, Green Jacket is from 1st series, Red jacket from the 2nd
Posts: 2,756
Threads: 41
Joined: Jan 2003
I have just watched the first few episodes of Lupin and from what I have seen the CN version must have been edited because there is no way that the unedited version would make it on to cable tv. (Those Bastards!!!) :mrgreen: :mrgreen:
Live life the way you want to, but one day, you might not wake up, and we all know why......
THERE ARE MAD KILLERS OUT THERE!!!
![[Image: optimisticox.jpg]](http://www.oldrepublic.net/optimisticox.jpg)
Posts: 4,254
Threads: 60
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 308
Threads: 42
Joined: Jan 2003
Also, an episode was cut from Pioneer's DVD release that has to do with Hitler. They said they will add it on a later DVD release.
Posts: 2,021
Threads: 446
Joined: Mar 2002
lol i swear soon there will be no middle east... it will be censored out from every publication/movie/cartoon etc etc ;p
Posts: 5,142
Threads: 126
Joined: Jun 2002
Sounds like a plan. :mrgreen:
Posts: 228
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2003
Meh, I've seen both versions of series 2 Lupin and I like what CN did with it. Both have their ups and downs, but I most definitely wouldn't describe the pioneer version as the "ruined" Lupin. The voice acting is generally superb for a dub (almost everything that shows up on CN has great voice acting) and some of the modern localizations and references are absolutely hilarious. I love how the American president sounded exactly like Clinton, etc etc. Plus they didn't sensor it quite as bad as you might think. Bastard, bitch, shit, and Jigen smoking his bong are all still in there. My advice - watch the CN Lupin because it's free, and if you like that buy it, because both are equally good.
o-('-')-o HuG
|)0Y: 1337 5p34k 4n0nyM0u5
Posts: 5,142
Threads: 126
Joined: Jun 2002
I'll still buy the Pioneer DVDs. :mrgreen:
Posts: 12
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2003
Does anyone happen to know offhand exactly what was cut from the second season which is being aired?
Posts: 2,721
Threads: 100
Joined: Sep 2002
Pioneer didn't just ruin Lupin (not Lu-Pon like they pronounce it) They raped it beyond recognition. That is a dub ALMOST as bad as DB but a few things are still worse. I CAN'T watch the dub of Lupin, even if I were going to make fun of it, it is that bad. Cartoon Network is doing a good job of promoting anime, YES. The anime being released having TOLERABLE dubs are far and few between, and Lupin is definitely NOT on MY list. Inu Yasha is a tolerable dub, all tthe Gundams EXCEPT G Gundam have decent dubs. Outlaw Star and Cowboy Bebop have watchable dubs as well. But as every veteran to this site knows, as if you couldn't tell, I HATE DUBS!!! They will never release a dubbed anime that I will like unless it is originally meant to be in English. The best intentional dubs are Blood the Last Vampire and Vampire Hunter D Blood Lust. Go figure they're both Vampire related. :roll:
- The Original Lord Of Darkness -
"Ahh The Murthless Laugh of the Damned"
Posts: 12
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2003
I am so happy that I was pronouncing his name right all that time. Now if I can just make myself stop saying Chobits wrong...
Posts: 2,721
Threads: 100
Joined: Sep 2002
Cho as in Show, Bits as in Cheese Nips! :mrgreen:
- The Original Lord Of Darkness -
"Ahh The Murthless Laugh of the Damned"
