A lot of people have reasons FOR disliking the other ones. It's the lamers who can never give actual facts behind it. They just say 'i hate that one'. For example, 8 is because i hated the gameplay (stocking crap and whatnot0, and 9 i hated the entire cast of characters. The sad part, is that both had fantastic stories, but i just can't get through them anymore.
Normally with an rpg, i can get through them just fine if they have a fantastic story. (takes legend of dragoon for example. soooo many people hate the game, but i find it rather enjoyable) Cause honestly, that's all that matters to me in an rpg. But when they have annoying gameplay 'quirks', then it's harder for me to get through them again (when i could much rather being playing something i enjoy more). And in 9's case, having a cast of overly annoying characters makes a game unplayable. Cause like i said, it's not like they were bad games, i just didn't like them.
In the end, it's all a matter of opinion. Which is what a lot of people just don't understand. They think THEIR opinion is the right one, and that is that.
Normally with an rpg, i can get through them just fine if they have a fantastic story. (takes legend of dragoon for example. soooo many people hate the game, but i find it rather enjoyable) Cause honestly, that's all that matters to me in an rpg. But when they have annoying gameplay 'quirks', then it's harder for me to get through them again (when i could much rather being playing something i enjoy more). And in 9's case, having a cast of overly annoying characters makes a game unplayable. Cause like i said, it's not like they were bad games, i just didn't like them.
In the end, it's all a matter of opinion. Which is what a lot of people just don't understand. They think THEIR opinion is the right one, and that is that.