01-06-2005, 11:04 AM
I would never of given that a bad rating... The only bad ratings I give are for stuff that is one-word answers like "Good" and that's it. Or for an R1 rip when people write "No engrish" and nothing else and don't mention in their review if the set is R1 ripped or not so you're left feeling like they could be fansubs etc... What we need is a sort of comment box or something... I do think we should keep the ratings but I didn't know people were giving bad ones for no reason... Even if I didn?t like someone I wouldn?t give a bad rating because it's not fair to people who want to buy the set and aren?t sure if the review is correct or not. We need comment boxes so we can clear up confusion over sets that have two reviews each conflicting as well... Look at this one http://import-anime.com/review.php?item_id=1883 the guy who is like 'how crap!! this would be one of the worst subs i've seen so far!!' yet he still gives them three and a half stars while others give them four and a half!